Low Carb Diet Best for Obesity According to Swedish Health Authorities

Low carb diet best for obesitySix months ago I wrote a blog post named “Low Carb Diets and Heart Disease. What Are We Afraid of? One of the concluding remarks of my article was: “I look forward to the day when low-carb, high-fat diets are accepted by public health representatives and medical associations for the treatment of obesity, metabolic syndrome and type 2 diabetes“.

Well, this day may actually have arrived sooner than I expected because today Swedish health authorities published a report (Dietary Approach for Obesity. A Systematic Review of the Literature) concluding that carbohydrate restriction is the best short term dietary approach to lose weight for people with obesity. Furthermore, they concluded that the current scientific literature does not indicate that such an approach has any harmful effects on health as so many have suggested.

SBU (Swedish Council on Health Technology Assessment) is a group of experts appointed by Swedish authorities, whose role is to update health care professionals on the best available diagnostic and treatment options for diverse medical conditions. SBU’s reports are based on systematic reviews of the available medical literature. Their approach is standardized and well tested. SBU has been performing systematic reviews since 1987, and they consider themselves to be one of the oldest and best established Health Technology Assessment Organization in the world.

Today SBU published their systematic analysis of currently available scientific studies on different dietary approaches for the treatment of obesity. Their review deals with studies on individuals with a BMI higher than 30 kg/m, generally defined as obesity. A total of 16.000 published scientific papers were analyzed.

Low carb diet best for obesity

SBU concludes that during short term (less than 6 months), dietary advice emphasizing moderate or strict carbohydrate restriction is more effective in terms of weight loss, than advice emphasizing a low fat diet. During long term, there are no differences in weight loss between moderate or strict carbohydrate restriction, low fat diets, high protein diets, a Mediterranean diet, a low GI-diet, or a diet rich in monounsaturated fatty acids. Advice to increase the consumption of dairy products (milk in particular) or reduce the amount of sugary beverages may induce weight loss as well.

The Swedish experts conclude that available scientific evidence does not support that advising moderate or strict carbohydrate restriction will increase the risk of heart disease. Even low carb diets containing high amounts of saturated fat have not been shown to increase risk. However, they emphasize that because of the lack of reliable studies, it would be rational to limit the amount of saturated fat under these circumstances : “…it’s not possible to draw any conclusions about the relationship between a low-carbohydrate diet – regardless of fat content – and cardiovascular disease. Here we could apply the precautionary principle, and advise some restraint on saturated fat intake, as long as the documentation of the long-term effects are inadequate.”

Jonas Lindblom, who lead the group of experts that wrote the report says that the results should encourage health professionals to inform individuals with obesity about the efficacy of carbohydrate restriction. “We did not find any scientific support for the conclusion that carbohydrate restriction may increase the risk of heart disease or increase mortality”, he said.

The SBU report also contains data indicating that low carb diets lead to better blood sugar levels than low fat diets among individuals with obesity and diabetes.

D-Day for LCHF

In my blog post six months ago I wrote: “I find it extraordinary how carbohydrate restriction is repeatedly rejected by the medical community as an alternative approach for obesity, the metabolic syndrome and type 2 diabetes. Obesity has reached epidemic proportions in many countries around the world. Diabetes and other obesity related disorders have become increasingly common. Public health organizations and medical societies usually advocate a low-fat, high-carbohydrate, energy-deficient diet to manage weight. Nonetheless, clinical experience and scientific studies indicate that other approaches may be more effective”.

By their systematic review, health authorities in the Sweden are among the first in the world to acknowledge the huge potential of carbohydrate restriction to treat conditions such as obesity, metabolic syndrome and type 2 diabetes. I do hope this is only the beginning and that health authorities elsewhere will follow in their footsteps. There is very much at stake because obesity and its metabolic and cardiovascular consequences are becoming very serious health issues of pandemic proportions.  We should not accept that effective weapons to fight these disorders are left unused.

advertisement

17
Leave a Reply

avatar
5 Comment threads
12 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
6 Comment authors
JeffMieRichard Mjödstånkacharles grashowDoc´s opinion Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
charles grashow
Guest
charles grashow

it’s not possible to draw any conclusions about the relationship between a low-carbohydrate diet – regardless of fat content – and cardiovascular disease. Here we could apply the precautionary principle, and advise some restraint on saturated fat intake, as long as the documentation of the long-term effects are inadequate.

How much restraint on saturated fat?

Axel F Sigurdsson
Admin
Axel F Sigurdsson

Charles. It´s not specified in the report.

Richard Mjödstånka
Guest
Richard Mjödstånka

According to SBU, there’s no evidence that LCHF diet elevates serum cholesterol. Phew…..they have should have asked you, Doc. You’ve actually treated patients. This was an expert group without the experts. Many of LCHF studies promoted and sponsored by the Atkins foundation do not even report LDL cholesterol (see the papers by Shai et al) . Hernandez et al indeed did indeed report LDL and it didn’t look too nice; the participants in the LCHF group lost 6 kg’s and despite of this weight loss the LDL went up by 10%. “Low-fat”-group dropped weight as much as the LCHF -group… Read more »

FrankG
Guest
FrankG

Still playing your disingenuous games with “LDL cholesterol” Richard? You don’t really think that a calculated LDL “volume” is all that matters do you? How many balls does it take to fill a garbage sack Richard? Do you think the answer might depend on what kind of balls these are? Would you rather be hit you over the head with a bag full of beach balls, or golf balls Richard? Same “volume ” in both… right?!? Perhaps the Atkins funded studies do not report this magic number because it is largely meaningless in terms of predicting long-term health. Let’s talk… Read more »

charles grashow
Guest
charles grashow

https://www.lecturepad.org/dayspring/lipidaholics/pdf/LipidaholicsCase291.pdf Let’s get rid of the nonsense seen all over the internet that atherosclerosis is an inflammatory disease, not a cholesterol disease. That is baloney-with the reality being that it is both. One cannot have atherosclerosis without sterols, predominantly cholesterol being in the artery wall: No cholesterol in arteries – no atherosclerosis. Plenty of folks have no systemic vascular inflammation and have atherosclerotic plaque. However clinicians have no test that measures cholesterol within the plaque – it is measured in the plasma. It is assumed, that if total or LDL-C or non-HDL-C levels are elevated the odds are good that… Read more »

Axel F Sigurdsson
Admin
Axel F Sigurdsson

Charles. Thanks for quoting Dr. Thomas Dayspring. Nobdy can beat him when it comes to explaining these issues. The first paragraph underlines the importance of understanding that both cholesterol and inflammation play a role in atherosclerosis, it´s not one or the other. The second paragraph deals with the extreme elevation of LDL-C and LDL-P sometimes seen among people on a ketogenic diet consuming a high amount of saturated fat. We still don´t know what this means in terms of risk.

charles grashow
Guest
charles grashow

So – would it not be more responsible for the SBU to give some guidelines on % of saturated fat to be consumed?

Axel F Sigurdsson
Admin
Axel F Sigurdsson

Charles. SBU´s role is not write guidelines or give recommendations. Their role is to perform systematic analyses and summarize results on currently available scientific evidence in different areas of medicine.

FrankG
Guest
FrankG

I agree with these points Charles… all of which goes to underline my intention which is that: a focus only on the LDL-C “level” (which is really a calculated volume) by itself, is not very helpful and can be downright misleading — which I believe was Richard’s intention.

Richard Mjödstånka
Guest
Richard Mjödstånka

FrankG, the Atkins crew love the HDL-C and triglyceride sales pitch. It’s their thing. These markers have little to do with diet composition as such and they respond favorable to weight loss independent of the mechanism used (See Stamler 2010). Amphetamines and chemotherapy all work as well on these biomarkers. So, let’s get not get blinded! The LDL story is fundamentally different! Fat is the new gospel at the moment, and the SBU went along this fad. However, fiber is gradually making a comeback from the 1990s. Soon we are asking whether this new fat craze went a bit too… Read more »

Axel F Sigurdsson
Admin
Axel F Sigurdsson

Richard. The SBU does not write guidelines or give recommendations on which therapy to use or not. They have not chosen to follow one fad or another. Their results are based on systematic analysis of 16.000 scientific papers. It´s not cherry picking. Their work cannot be ignored. Although you have other beliefs, it may be irresponsible and unrational to just look in a different direction. At least such an attitude does not reflect belief in scientific methodology. Furthermore, it´s important to keep in mind that SBU´s report only deals with dietary tretament of obesity. The results cannot be extrapolated to… Read more »

Richard Mjödstånka
Guest
Richard Mjödstånka

Doc, are you serious? The only way to make LCHF look good is to compare it to a strawman diet composed of cookies, soda, etc, the “the 15g/d fiber diet”. Weight loss is not a synonym with health. There are very quick ways to loose lot of weight very rapidly (and enhance triglycerides and HDL-C cholesterol) without any adverse effects on LDL; these are acquiring food poisoning, chemotherapy, amphetamines, etc. Why did you enunciate me being a cherry-picker? We both agree that LCHF elevates serum cholesterol, the SBU disagreed, according to them they found no evidence of LCHF and adverse… Read more »

Mie
Guest
Mie

Richard, you’re talking baloney here:

1) In many studies low carb diets have indeed been compared to the standard Western diet, yes. Just like low fat vegan diets. Hmm? Catch my point?

2) Not in all, however. E.g. this one

https://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=205916

or this one

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15632335

both of compared Atkins and Ornish, among other diets. Of course, if you wish to argue that Ornish is a strawman diet, be my guest.

And while weight loss is not necessarily a synonym for health, it is usually a synonym for improved lipid profile, glucose tolerance etc.

charles grashow
Guest
charles grashow

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3751676/ Longitudinal analysis of short-term high-fat diet on endothelial senescence in baboons “…our results clearly established that 1) even a short-term exposure (7 weeks) to a high-fat diet can have devastating pathological effects on vascular endothelial cells, and 2) physiological responses during the first 3 weeks of high-fat diet may have lasting effects that are manifested in endothelial cells at a later time. These conclusions significantly impact the traditional perception that a high-fat diet is detrimental only if exposure to it is of long duration. They also have important implications for the design of experiments aimed at understanding the progression… Read more »

charles grashow
Guest
charles grashow

https://circ.ahajournals.org/content/116/16/1832.full

Subendothelial Lipoprotein Retention as the Initiating Process in Atherosclerosis

The key initiating process in atherogenesis is the subendothelial retention of apolipoprotein B–containing lipoproteins. Local biological responses to these retained lipoproteins, including a chronic and maladaptive macrophage- and T-cell–dominated inflammatory response, promote subsequent lesion development. The most effective therapy against atherothrombotic cardiovascular disease to date—low density lipoprotein–lowering drugs—is based on the principle that decreasing circulating apolipoprotein B lipoproteins decreases the probability that they will enter and be retained in the subendothelium.

Jeff
Guest
Jeff

I am a novice at all the talk of diets and way of eating plans. I can say I just finished a low fat low carb (vegetarian) way of eating and had a lipid test after four months. HDL rose slightly to 37, TG fell from 211 to 92 and total dropped to 156. I was taking a low dose 10mg statin irregularly meaning not every day as the doctor prescribed. When I did take it every day that is when the LDL was 82. My wife recently went from vegetarian to LCHF and enjoys this way of eating over… Read more »

Jeff
Guest
Jeff

After thought …. my LDL was 100 on the lipid test with irregular use of the 10mg statin and being on a vegetarian diet.

Tweet
Pin
Share243
Share3